Wafa Sultan on Al Jazeera TV to Muslim Fundamentalists: Re-examine Dogma

michael balcom says:

January 21, 2009 at 5:58 pm

TYPICAL ILLITERATE NON MUSLIM SHE DOES NOT RECOGNIZE WHY CERTAIN THINGS WERE SAID AND IN WHAT CONTEXT AND WHAT CONDITIONS HAVE TO BE MET…NO WONDER THE WESTERN WORLD IS CORRUPT IN WAYS YOU CANNOT EVEN IMAGINE AND IN SOME CASES SEE. ALSO ADULTERY IS RAMPANT ! SHE IS A FRUSTRATED TYPICAL WOMAN FROM A COUNTRY THAT DOES NOT ALLOW PEOPLE TO MAKE THEIR OWN CHOICES AND PEOPLE ARE ASKED TO FOLLOW BLINDLY. SHE SHOULD DO HER OWN RESEARCH AND GAIN A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF ISLAM I BET SHE DOES NOT KNOW TOO MUCH EXCEPT STONING AND HAS EVEN TAKEN THAT OUT OF CONTEXT
fadingad says:

January 21, 2009 at 9:28 pm

I can’t imagine a context where stoning is an appropriate response or resolution. Barbarism is barbarism no matter what context. The US treatment of prisoners in Abu Ghraib was barbaric no matter how you frame it. The way prisoners in Guantanamo are being treated is criminal. So too are the ways women are treated in Islamic countries with Sharia law. You speak of adultery. Why is the woman stoned? Why not castrate the male? Neither is acceptable behavior. Homosexuals are being hanged in Iran. I thought Allah was merciful? Perhaps he is. The hangmen are not.

Search